For more than a decade, the Democratic Party’s strategic soul has been defined by one name: Obama. His playbook. His operatives. His coalition. His tone. His style. For years, it was the gold standard—the model of modern Democratic success.
But after the humiliating defeat of Kamala Harris in 2024, the post-Biden reckoning has begun in full force. And at the center of the storm is a simple, brutal realization: the Obama machine no longer works.
Kamala Harris turned to Jim Messina—Barack Obama’s 2012 campaign manager—hoping to resurrect some of that old magic. But Messina wouldn’t touch the campaign with a 10-foot pole. “You’re going to be a loser,” longtime Democratic megadonor John Morgan told him bluntly. “And your whole shine is you’re undefeated.”
Messina walked away. David Plouffe, however, didn’t. The once-revered mastermind of Obama’s 2008 run joined Harris’ campaign—and now carries the sting of one of the Democratic Party’s most high-profile collapses. “The shine’s off Plouffe now,” Morgan declared. “He’s just an old broken-down boy, who lost. Big.”
The verdict from party insiders is even sharper: The Obama era’s stars became liabilities, clinging to the same formulas in a radically different political landscape.
The 2024 election saw the collapse of the so-called Obama coalition—young voters, less politically engaged voters, and voters of color. Many of them shifted to Donald Trump in staggering numbers. The problem isn’t just that the coalition failed—it’s that it no longer exists.
The generation that was electrified by “Yes We Can” now has kids, mortgages, and a front-row seat to inflation. Meanwhile, the new generation doesn’t remember Obama at all—they came of age during Trump, not hope and change.
And now, those Obama-era architects who once reshaped Democratic politics are being asked a harsh question: what have you done for us lately?
David Plouffe tried to push the blame onto Joe Biden, declaring in a new book that “he totally f—ed us.” That triggered a backlash from inside the house. DNC finance chair Chris Korge snapped back, calling Plouffe and his ilk the “so-called gurus,” adding: “The old Obama playbook no longer works.”
Jane Kleeb, a party vice chair from Nebraska, wasn’t interested in hearing from the “Pod Save America guys” or New York PR shops when Republicans targeted a mayoral candidate in Omaha over transgender issues. Her team didn’t reach for high-priced consultants—they grabbed a whiteboard, ran with “potties vs. potholes,” and won by 13 points.
Why? Because they actually know what voters on the ground care about.
From Stephanie Cutter to Rufus Gifford, Obama’s consultants still dominate DNC influence, media prep, and donor management. But activists like David Hogg—now a DNC vice chair himself—are calling for blood. He says the “operative class” is just as entrenched as aging lawmakers, and just as reluctant to make way for the next generation.
“It’s time to re-evaluate the use of consultants and bring in new forward-looking people,” Korge echoed.
Strategist Chris Kofinis put it bluntly: “I don’t want a surgeon who keeps killing patients.” And he’s right. Experience doesn’t equal relevance. Winning with Obama in 2008 or 2012 doesn’t mean you know how to defeat Trump in 2028.
The Democratic Party now faces an unambiguous fork in the road.
-
Keep recycling the same consultants, strategies, and personalities who hitched their reputations to Obama’s aura, or
-
Hand over the reins to a new generation of operatives, organizers, and candidates with different instincts, deeper local ties, and a fresh view of today’s electorate.
Ammar Moussa, who worked for both Biden and Harris, sees the turnover happening already—but slowly. “It’s incumbent upon the senior consulting class to know what they don’t know,” he said. That might be the understatement of the year.
